Discussion (162) ¬
[ Comments RSS ]
Sheryl Weikal (The Leftist Lawyer) @leftistlawyer.com ⋅ 3h
Polling USA @usapolling.bsky.social ⋅ 4h
onion person @junlper.beer ⋅ 8h
David M Willis! @damnyouwillis.bsky.social ⋅ 3d
Ari Drennen @aridrennen.bsky.social ⋅ 2d
David M Willis! @damnyouwillis.bsky.social ⋅ 16d
Loading ...
PAX East
Wait just happened?
Dotty said the story was dumb and Roz agreed with her, which clearly Dotty didn’t expect.
Who the feck is Dotty?
Dorothy.
Dorothy of cause, Dotty is a common nickname for Dorothy where I’m from.
Where?
Australia
And everywhere else, too.
You’re from everywhere?!
Everywhere is located in 11700 Preston Road, Dallas, TX according to Google Maps
It… it is? That’s near where I live. I’ll have to go visit Everywhere.
Everywhere
11700 Preston Road, Dallas, TX …
I’m pretty sure that is just a Whole Foods… not everywhere.
Holy crap. Inputting address into phone navigator RIGHT NOW. I could drive to Everywhere in half an hour, tops.
@Blob Marley
When you’re done with that, there’s a really neat all-you-can-eat Sushi place about five minutes away on Belt Line. Y’know, so you actually get something other than a trip to Whole Foods/Staples
I did a screen capture of where Everywhere is on the Australian Google Maps.
http://i1191.photobucket.com/albums/z479/Plasma-Mongoose/EverywhereTX.gif
Everywhere else
Oz, you mean.
Dotty is clearly a nickname for Dorothy, but while I know a few Dorothys, the only one I have heard being called Dotty is my grandmother. So while Dorothy sounds like a general name to me, Dotty sounds like a little old lady name.
NOW THAT’S JUST DOTTY
Let me get this straight.
Dotty=Dorothy
Tubs=Billie
Freckles=Ruth
Mike=Mike
Am I missing anyone?
How do you get Dotty from Dorothy?
The same way people get Dick from Richard.
Buy him dinner and maybe a take him to a movie?
WITH HIS PENIS?
The same way you get Maggie from Margo.
or Chuck from Charles, or Bob from Robert, or Jack from John…
Wait, I didn’t know about Jack and John.
Or “Hodge” from “Roger”… that one kind of went by the wayside though.
The way they somehow get Daisy, Gretel, Peggy or Rita from Margaret.
Or “Bill” from “William”.
I can’t speak to Daisy or Gretel, but the other two diminutives of Margaret make linguistic sense. The name Margaret is derived from the Greek word μαργαρίτης (margarites, for those of you who don’t read Greek), which means ‘Pearl.’ Rita comes from the final syllables of ‘margarita,’ the Latin equivalent of the Greek word (and also a very tasty drink). ‘Peggy’ derives from an Irish Gaelic word that also means ‘pearl.’
I only know this because I have a sister named Margaret, and she learned these factoids in order to justify being called Peggy.
A quick internet search (because I have no life) indicated that ‘Gretel’ derives from a Germanic word meaning ‘pearl.’ The internet’s claim to Daisy also being a diminutive of Margaret is that the French word for ‘daisy’ (the flower) is ‘marguerite,’ which is pronounced a lot like ‘Margaret.’
I had a good friend proudly inform me that he had named his newborn son after his and his wife’s grandfathers. The boy was Harold Richard …, the look of horror on his face when I reminded him of that the nicknames were was priceless . Personnally I would have named him Harold William.
The same way you get Jack from Jonathan.
……Okay I know you are making that one up.
Actually they’re not making that one up. Though it also is a nickname for John. Given I know of at least 2 people who are named John but get called Jack, it’s not all that uncommon.
The root name for both Jack and John is Yochanon. It’s the old Hebrew version of Jonathon. The ch is sort of a cat-with-a-hairball noise.
I’m pretty sure John and Jonathan actually come from different (though similar-sounding) Hebrew names– Yohannon is John
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_(given_name))
and Yonatan or Yehonatan is Jonathan (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_(name)).
@Mkvenner
Making it up? You kidding?
Pop culture, book by Julian May: “Jack the Bodiless.” Nickname for Jon Remillard
U.S. Politics: John F. Kennedy, “Jack Kennedy”
Honestly, the phonetic transformation from “Dorothy” to “Dotty” is so direct as nicknames go that I’m having trouble seeing how you can be having trouble with it. “Dotty” is just “Dorothy” spoken with a lack of precision, right? Think of the “Putting On the Ritz” scene from Young Frankenstein, but imagine that instead of trying to say “Putting On the Ritz” and coming out with “POO’EEN ON A REEEEES”, he’s trying to say “Dorothy”. It would sound pretty much like “DOOOOOTEEEEE”.
How you get Polly from Mary has always been a mystery to me, though.
Or “Sally” from “Sarah.”
Salvador!
Or “Susan” from “Thrakkorzog”?
Now you’re doing it on purpose.
The same why you get Jack from Orville.
Way, too.
Walky=David.
How could I miss that?
From his last name, Walkerton.
People sometimes call me by my last name too, specially when there is more than one Fred
Yeah, I get that a lot too IRL, especially at work where we’ve gone through several people with the same first name as me over the years I’ve been there.
Sal=Batman
Joyce=Blue eyes white devil.
Amazi-Girl=UltraCar (or) Gallasso (or) Abe Lincoln.
Actually, AAAAAAAH = Mike.
Mike+Your mom = a nickel
I’m done. I will not pursue this line of commenting anymore, as it has become rather silly.
What, no nimb?
You’re no fun anymore.
NIMB?
I meant nibble.
NIMH?
Now, I’ve noticed a tendency for this forum to get rather silly. I do my best to keep things moving along, and I’m not having things getting silly. Those last two forums I posted on gat rather silly indeed, and that last one about the necks got even sillier. Now, nobody likes o good laugh more than I do, exept perhaps my brother, and some of his friends. And my dog. Come to think of it, most people like a good laugh more than I do, but that’s beside the point. Now lets have a good, clean, healthy, outdoor forum. Get some air into your lungs! Ten, nine, eight and all that!
Awww, you’re just upset ‘cuz you couldn’t think of a punchline.
Dorothy lost her femurs.
Dotty isn’t taking that comment too well it seems.
She isn’t taking the story too well, also.
“Wow, she actually just said that, didn’t she?”
What is the answer that Roz wanted to hear?
You meant Dotty right?
No, Roz said that Dotty’s comment is pretty close to the one she wanted to hear. So, the question remains, what is the answer Roz really wanted to hear?
My guess? That it’s a pointless story not worth having.
She’s doing damage control, is my guess. She knows she’ll be watched. So she’s going with scandal right off. A really stupid scandal. “college girl has sex” is basically what it is. Which, honestly, is about as surprising and shocking as “college boy gets paddled to join frat”.
There’s really little story here. So when it’s over and done with, nobody will care when she keeps doing it. Which keeps robin safe. Unless it’s a huge scandal, those things only hurt enough to decide elections if they happen right before an election. By election time far fewer people will care, especially as Robin has no doubt secured world peace.
The difference between a representative’s sister’s sex scandal and a pledge getting paddled is the pledge getting paddled is illegal. And it actually is surprising and shocking these days, in large part because of that fact. As a fraternity alum, I resent the implications you have made about fraternities.
Something to the lines of “Do you want an interview?”
I’m thinking Roz dislikes the fact that sex (specifically, sex between consenting adults) is seen as a moral or important issue. Knowing that the journalism student working on the story thinks the story is meaningless and stupid gives her hope for journalism and how people view sex in the future.
She’s let down by the ableist language though, hence the ‘pretty close’, but it looks like she’s taking what she can get.
She wanted to hear “No, I’m not excited to write about something so normal as sex just because it will titilate the repressed masses who are only interested because one of the people having sex is related to somebody important.”
That, or she wanted to be propositioned.
That’s an answer I can get behind.
You really should have had a Joe gravatar to post that.
Are you also into girls?
Are you answering the question or are you talking to me?
Answering the question.
Although…
Put words in mouth at your own peril.
Mkvenner, your grav is perfect for that comment.
I hate turning you into ammo that your sister’s enemies can use against her.
She wanted to hear, “I’m excited, but not about the story.”
Dislike Roz.
Agree. She’s unpleasant for the exact same reason Joyce is. They both have a preconceived idea about how people should think and think it’s their primary responsibility to fix any divergence. On the other hand, at least Joyce seems capable of dealing with people outside of that context. So far, every single thing Roz has done has been in service of her crusade.
Including Joe?
I saw what you did there.
Yes, very definitely including Joe.
What crusade is this again?
Don’t call this a Crusade. I’m sure either JMS or TBS will run in, cancel it midway through the arc and leave us all hanging for the next several decades.
Ooh, a Babylon 5 universe reference?? And I didn’t even care for Crusade that much. Prefered B5 way over it.
Anyway, nice twist Walky. Be interesting to see where it goes next.
suddenly liking Roz despite myself – provisionally, of course. Depends on whether this was all meant to be a statement, or just a jab at her sister.
I like Roz myself, but then again, I seem to like Faz and Malaya in Shortpacked! so you can make whatever conclusions you will from these facts.
I hate Malaya!! But I also like Roz and Faz. Faz is too funny. I hope he makes an appearance in DOA!!
i can only see faz appearing as someone’s sibling or as a child prodigy that made it in. alas, my preferred scenario seems the least likely.
I would like to see a Faz show up as a teacher. >:D
I like how Dorothy is sitting there with her hands all properly folded, sitting in “high judgement” of Roz’s “loose morals”.
Then: BAM! Right in the face with a sweet pickle pie! (Ultracar may not exist in this continuity, but the pies should!)
For shame, Dotty. You’re using ableist language in front of Roz.
I’m suddenly realizing that everything becomes ten times more hilarious when you’ve got Walky beaming and giving it two thumbs up right next to your comment.
It’s also funny when it’s positive and you have Mike glaring.
Oh yeeeeah… I wonder if that was intentional?
God da… I draw the line at “dumb” being ableist language. Usage defines meaning. Dumb has meant unintelligent since the SIXTIES. It no longer refers to someone who is incapable of speech.
So sick of “ableist” language anyway. Not everything needs an “ist,” people.
That reminds me of the first time I ever read The Trumpet of the Swan when I was a little kid; I was so confused, “He’s a BIRD, how can you tell if he’s smart or not? Not being able to honk doesn’t mean he’s stupid! And how will giving him a trumpet make him less dumb?”
I have no idea how long it took me to figure out that “dumb” had another meaning I hadn’t known.
Pssst! I think she broke Dorothy.
Dorothy’s already broken by Joe, I think.
Dorothy already went to high school with him and dated his best friend/wingman.
So Joe doesn’t really bother her THAT much.
Really? Cause she really looked bothered in yesterday’s strip.
I think that was of annoyed than bothered.
what, you think she’s built up a resistance? I’d say that every time she has to interact with Joe, it chips away at her soul a little more – she put up with him in highschool for Danny’s sake, but like many women who do not want to have sex with Joe, she’s got a limited tolerance for his behavior.
If that was the case, then Joe needs to fix her again…
With his hammer.
His fists are not the hammer.
So no percussive maintenance?
I wouldn’t say that, a certain type of ‘pounding’ may be in order.
I’m going to have ask you to stop right there.
Only if you usen the safety word.
The safe word is “Femurs”.
That works for me.
Joe is Captain Hammer suddenly?
Mostly I’m trying to find new and exciting ways to cut off predictable memes before they start.
Granted, I used a meme from a different context, but it’s the best I could do as quickly as I could.
Then who’s Dr. Horrible?
And do they have a Sing Along blog?
It seems like most english words for unintelligent are ableist in some way, given that there didn’t used to be much of a conceptual distinction between “stupid” and “mentally handicapped”. Personally I’ll just stick with modern definitions, thanks, and consider any definition shift that’s over a century old to be grandfathered in. Which gives ‘dumb’ a free pass.
‘Unintelligent’ is every bit as much ableist as the rest of them. Calling someone mentally handicapped is the same as calling someone handicapped, just more specific. The real question is, why would you prefer to use words that are technically inaccurate, when accurate words are available to you? Is it somehow more insulting to call someone dumb than stupid?
I think the concept of ableist language is ridiculous, because it’s like getting offended at someone calling you a paraplegic when you’re blind. It’s got nothing to do with you if they don’t know how to describe it if your legs are fine but your eyes don’t work.
There’s nothing innaccurate about using the word “dumb” to mean “stupid”, since the word has held that meaning for over a hundred and fifty years. Calling the “stupid” usage “technically inaccurate” is like saying that using “fine” to mean “okay” and using “bill” to mean “legal paper” are inaccurate because “fine” means “punitive charge” and “bill” means “a duck’s mouth”. The simple fact is that lots of words have more than one meaning in English. We rely on context to tell them apart – and it’s rare for it to be unclear which you mean when you use “dumb”. (If it ever is confusing, it behooves you to use a different term in that instance.)
And incidentally, I’ve done a little poking around on the interwebs and seen it claimed that while prior to that the word “dumb” was occasionally used in the ableist fashion of “silent = stupid” back in the 1700s, it’s modern meaning seems to have mainly been borrowed from the German word “dumm”, an thus the modern sense of “dumb” = “stupid” isn’t actually ableist at all! In which case any accusations of ableism are based on (basically) homophone/homograph trouble. Who knew, eh?
Oh, and “unintelligent” is explicitly not ableist, since neither it nor its base term “intelligent” are a demarcation between handicapped and non-handicapped people.
“Dumb” means [rather, historically meant] mute, not mentally handicapped. You’re thinking of “idiot”.
Hence the pun in the song title “Free Speech For The Dumb”.
If we’re going to split hairs over it, you should know that the original meaning of ‘idiot’ is someone who keeps to himself and does not participate in politics, and it simply had the connotation of being stupid or uneducated based in the implication that any educated man would be interested in the workings of the polis, but over time the connotation overshadowed the actual definition.
I just have to say how much I love the fact that I was expecting to see sex talk and Roz bashing and we are instead getting a linguistics discussion. Gotta love this group.
Dumb means “stupid” and “mute”, nowadays. Neither definition is erroneous.
(And you can’t replace it with “idiot” – that’s a different part of speech. “Idiotic”, maybe, though I consider the two words to have different shades of meaning. You have to work a little harder to be idiotic; being dumb is easy and common.)
Oh snap!
D: Hey, roz isn’t doing this…to SPITE Robin…r-right?
I mean…c’mon…its her SISTER….Dx;
That’s so demeaning! Refering to Joe as a ‘story’! HE’S A HUMAN BEING!!
…I get a good laugh out of most of the comics. But I get an even BETTER laugh out of the comments left bellow them.
Below. >> -cough-
We try.
The comments do tend to be funnier if you bellow them.
WITH MY PENIS!!!!
Wow, you’re right, it is funnier!
I shall now try to interpret Dorothy’s thoughts!….”Was that thing I ate this morning still good?”…. What? Am I off?
I think it’s more like ” Why am I pissed off about all this? Oh right, Joe.”
I thought it was “What the fuck just happened?” or “Did that just happen?”
Se the way her mouth gets all small? That’s annoyance. She isn’t ticked about Joe or astonished about anything. She’s annoyed about something specific to the situation she is currently looking at.
Also, the eye tick suggests that it’s something she already knew was going to annoy her before it happened. I’m guessing she’s directly annoyed about the subtle dig at her use of the word ‘dumb’.
The way she is holding her hands together screams that her hands are thirsting necks.
I thought the mouth suggested stunned silence while the eyebrow was simply raised in curiosity. Kind of like in The Dark Knight when Joker crashed a party and an old mine said nobody was scared.
Yeah, it looks more like confusion to me. Pursing one’s lips and tilting one’s eyebrows often indicates confusion/puzzlement.
I agree. That is clearly a ‘…what!?’ eyetick.
I would imagine her next expression would a be a narrowed eyed, ‘I see what you did there’ look, followed by a growl of annoyance or a sigh of giving up.
“Call me Dottie and you die.”
– Dot Warner, Animaniacs.
My name is Princess Angelina Contesa Louisa Fancesca Banana-Fanna Bo Besca the Third.
Damn… I love that Roz prefers the truth to flattery. It honestly means that she prefers hearing the truth about herself instead of ‘flattery’ or ‘flaming’. If I wasn’t in love with the bow ties already, I’d fall in love with Roz for that alone.
But again, the bow ties own my heart, because bow ties are cool.
And so are fezzes.
Yes, but I’m sure Sal in this universe would pull out a gun and shoot any random Fez cause that’s just how she rolls.
Especially because Walky is the person most likely to wear a fez.
Okay, how many people think that she did to just to mess with Robin?
I think she had sex with Joe because she wanted to have sex. You don’t volunteer to wear a condom hat without having some pretty firm views on sexual liberation, which would seem to go hand in hand with being of the mind that your own genitals are there for you to use.
Mmmmmm…
If Dorothy’s close to telling Roz what she wants to hear, does this mean she gets free sex from her? Just in theory. Not shipping or anything.
I think Roz’s door swings both ways. As long as it’s fun and consentual between adults doesn’t matter who gets her off.
Not saying she’s a slut mind you; but there is a fine line between that and just being ‘free spirited’.
Phuh. Mind games.
Personally I think she’s just BSing.
On a second read, it seems that Dorothy is the jerk? She called her out just to tell her she doesn’t like having to write a story about her? First read I though she was trying to go somewhere with it, like “I don’t like it, you don’t like it but let’s both make the most of it” and showing frustration ‘d be justified if that’s the feeling she was trying to convey, but maybe she was just agitating her on purpose?
I’m confused. Roz’s response seems to imply that she think the big deal everyone is making about her and Joe having sex is a not a big deal. And considering her she’s all about Female Sexual empowerment (the condom hat…), that opinion would make sense. After all, sex isn’t really a big deal to the people who it doesn’t directly affect.
Buuuut… She went to the effort of putting the video online and getting a lot of attention for it, which implies she wants people to see it as a big deal.
So… I’m not sure what she’s aiming for. I mean, it feels a little beneath her to do this just to screw with Robin. Especially if the Robin in this universe is anything like the Robin in the Shortpacked Universe. After all, that Robin made a major aspect of her campaign two gay boys making out all lickity-style.
I think she’s just messing with Dorothy’s head to gain more attention, or her attention.
She could be posting the video online to make a big deal out of the ensuing discussion. As in “this video doesn’t affect you, why are you talking about it”.
So, no jokes about Dorothy going to Roz?